Only five players have won back back-to-back NFL MVP awards. Former Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers was the last to do it in 2020-2021. Mike De Sisti/Milwaukee Journal Sentinel/USA TODAY NETWORK / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
Aaron Rodgers couldn’t wait to jolt away from the Green Bay Packers and to the New York Jets in 2023.
The 2023 season felt like a turning point for Rodgers and the Packers. Green Bay’s slow start and Rodgers’ struggles with a young receiving corps led to frustrations that didn’t appear healable with Jordan Love biding his time in the background.
Two offseasons later, the four-time NFL MVP is deciding between the New York Giants and Pittsburgh Steelers as his destination for 2025. The “safe bet” appears that Rodgers will sign with the Steelers by April 9.
Rodgers’ ultimate decision this spring will likely feel more like his former home in Green Bay than his two-year stint in New York.
Aaron Rodgers wants a culture like the Green Bay Packers
Per Albert Breer of Sports Illustrated, Rodgers is looking for a “culture” like the one he had with the Packers. He values that culture more than he does money.
“While money is always a factor in the NFL, I don’t really get the idea it will be in this particular case, with either the New York Giants or the Steelers,” Breer wrote on Monday. “At this point, my sense is that whatever Rodgers decides will come down to what he sees as the best football situation. And along those lines, I’ve heard Rodgers is looking for a culture such as the one in Green Bay.
“I get it if that sounds a little strange after the drama of the four-time MVP’s final years as a Packer. But over the past few months, Rodgers has been open with people around him on his renewed appreciation for what he had for 18 seasons in Wisconsin. Call it a grass-is-greener dynamic if you want, but it definitely has felt, to some of those around him, like spending a couple years as a New York Jet made Rodgers view the situation he had more favorably.”
Rodgers didn’t seem to like the Packers’ culture at the end
The Packers always had a strong culture, but it was Rodgers typically butting heads with organization leaders trying to keep the foundation sound. He didn’t like OTAs or many of the choices the Packers made during the draft, free agency, or the trade deadline.
The Steelers operate similarly to the Packers. They build through the draft and expect their players to work in the offseason.
Some lessons are learned the hard way. Frankly, only an idiot would to the Jets as a place to find a stable culture.
The Steelers will offer Rodgers a strong culture with a veteran roster that can win a Super Bowl. Can Rodgers stay grounded for a whole season to make a contract worth it for Pittsburgh?
