With MLB The Show 25 set to officially release on March 18, and preorders opening this Friday, San Diego Studios has recently unveiled their player ratings for the latest installment of the game.
This makes it an ideal moment to break down how the White Sox players are rated and what it means for the team heading into the season.
Unfortunately for White Sox fans, the team’s ratings don’t look great at first glance, but they provide insight into how the roster stacks up heading into the season.
No Gold-Tier Players
The White Sox didn’t land a single gold-tier player in MLB The Show 25, leaving the roster without a high-impact player to anchor the team.
If the team were to trade Luis Robert Jr., their highest-rated player, the roster would become even more depleted from a ratings standpoint, making an already weak lineup even less competitive.
Without a standout, high-rated player, the team lacks a go-to option in online modes or Franchise Mode. This drop-off mirrors the real-life uncertainty surrounding the roster, making it a tough year for White Sox fans looking for impact players in the game.
The Sox have only seven players with an overall rating over 70.
Luis Robert Jr.’s rating is the highest at 77.
Robert Jr. experienced one of the most significant rating drops among White Sox players, with his overall falling from 89 to 77 while also seeing a noticeable decline in key attributes.
His offensive attributes, particularly his power against right-handed pitchers, suffered a major hit, dropping from 90 last year to 75 this year. His contact against left-handed pitchers also declined from 92 to a lower mark, making him a less effective hitter overall.
Additionally, his fielding rating dropped from 79, and his overall defensive ratings have declined.
Durability and plate vision appear to be the primary reasons behind his drop-off, as concerns about his ability to maintain elite performance over a full season have grown. His plate vision likely took a hit due to his struggles at the plate last season, where he posted a .244 batting average.
Penn Murfee is rated 75 overall.
Murfee surprisingly lands as the second-highest-rated player on the team with a 75 overall. He is already a well-known name among MLB The Show players, particularly in online game modes like Battle Royale, where his funky delivery makes him a valuable bullpen option.
Five players check in with a 73 overall rating
Mike Tauchman’s ranking makes him a solid but unspectacular option for outfield depth. While not a game-changer, his balanced ratings make him a useful role-player in Franchise Mode.
Davis Martin, the highest-rated starting pitcher on the team, could hint at his potential role as the Opening Day starter for the White Sox. His rating suggests he is a serviceable arm but not necessarily a dominant force on the mound.
Bryse Wilson also holds a 73 overall rating, providing depth to the rotation or bullpen. He doesn’t possess elite attributes but can be a steady presence for the White Sox in simulations or lower-tier matchups.
Michael A. Taylor is the best defensive player on the team, boasting 90+ ratings in fielding, arm strength, and accuracy. His elite glove makes him an excellent platoon option for Andrew Benintendi or Mike Tauchman in Franchise Mode.
Mike Clevinger rounds out the top-rated players on the team with a 73 overall. With the current roster construction, he is contending for a high-leverage bullpen role that could potentially make him the team’s closer, providing a veteran presence at the back end of the bullpen.
Top Prospects and Future Ratings
One of the biggest unknowns heading into MLB The Show 25 is how the White Sox’s young talent will be rated.
Braden Montgomery, who was selected 12th overall by the Boston Red Sox before being traded to the White Sox in the Garrett Crochet deal, may have a low overall due to not yet playing in a minor league game, but he should carry a high potential rating.
His potential rating will determine how quickly he can develop and contribute to the major league roster. If given strong potential ratings, these prospects could be just a few seasons away from making an impact on the virtual White Sox roster.
Players like Noah Schultz and Colson Montgomery have yet to receive official ratings, but it’s safe to assume they will fall in the 60s overall range. Catchers Edgar Quero and Kyle Teel are also expected to have solid potential and respectable overalls behind the plate, making them valuable future assets in Franchise Mode.
If given strong potential ratings, these top prospects could be just a few seasons away from making an impact on the virtual White Sox roster.
Positive Takeaways
While the White Sox have some of the lowest-rated players in the game, players interested in Diamond Dynasty should take advantage of the low prices of White Sox cards.
These lower-rated cards can be flipped for profit or used to earn better cards through collections and challenges. Their roster could still provide value in certain game modes. Players looking to build a competitive team on a budget may find useful pieces within the roster, whether in Franchise Mode or online play.
The MLB The Show 25 ratings for the White Sox aren’t pretty, but they paint a realistic picture of where the team stands heading into the season. With no gold-tier players and a drastic drop for Luis Robert Jr., it’s clear the team has a lot to prove both on the field and in the digital realm.